Here is the description not of a legal, but a "life" case of how one artist attracted general public’s attention to NFT topic, started extensive conversations around it and essentially paved the way for many digital artists using this tool.
Maria Boicova-Wynants
European Trademark Attorney, Partner at Starks IP and International Trade law firm (www.starks.be), Mediator
Beeple: the dawn of the insaNFTy
It all started in late 2020.
As a disclaimer, the NFT story has, of course, started much earlier. Seven years before the whole world heard of the insane price a .jpeg file can bring at Christie’s auction, on the 3rd of May, 2014, digital artist Kevin McCoy minted the first-known NFT, called 'Quantum' on the Namecoin blockchain. Back then, I bet it would have been difficult to find even a dozen people who had heard the acronym which seems to be on everyone’s lips nowadays. But let us go back to October 2020 and Mike Winkelmann, a digital artist who goes by the name Beeple.
October 2020. This was around that period that Beeple decided to jump on the highly accelerating NFT wagon, greatly contributing to it getting traction. However, important to stress is that back then, he had already been creating and posting digital artworks online for 13,5 years.
Every (!) single day for 13,5 (!) years, till the total reached 5.000 (Hence the subsequent name — “Everydays: The first 5000 days.”)
The first digital artwork of this series was published on his blog on the 1st of May, 2007[1].
One can disagree on the artistic quality of some (or all) of Beeple’s artworks, yet one certainly cannot deny him his mind-blowing tenacity.
In 2021, the artist had a significant number of followers on his Instagram account, while the community of digital artists was buzzing about this new “thing” — non-fungible tokens. Why not give it a shot? Which Beeple also did in October 2020, launching three artworks on Nifty Gateway for as little as a dollar apiece. Two months later, Beeple’s other drop “The Complete MF Collection” attracted a staggering bid of USD 777.777,77 from Tim Kang, who also owns several of Beeple’s “Politics is Bullshit” from his very first drop (Nr. 33/100 and 100/100).
Beeple got interested. Really interested.
Fast forward just three more months and an NFT of a mosaic of his 5000 artworks entitled “Everydays: The First 5000 Days,” was auctioned at Christie’s. The bidding started at a hundred dollars, yet on March 11th, 2021 the art market was “crashed” with a hammer price in excess of sixty-nine million dollars coming out of the wallet of an NFT fund Metapurse, led by Vignesh Sundaresan, a.k.a. MetaKovan.
The tenacity of Beeple paid out at a rate of about USD 14,000 per day, while Christie’s scored yet another digital “first” (three years after auctioning the first “AI-generated” artwork, “Portrait of Edmond Belamy” for USD 432,500).
The art market would never be the same.
And the art market was starting to talk. Intensively and extensively. Eventually, it was followed pretty much by everyone, yet back then, in 2021, it was primarily the art market talking.
Noah Davis, Christie’s Post-War and Contemporary Art Specialist in New York, said: “Beeple is looking at his whole body of work as it’s presented on Instagram as a kind of Duchampian readymade”. Ironically, Beeple himself, who never studied modern art, when asked, for example, about Abstract expressionism, admitted that he literally, has “no idea what the hell that is”. Would he be able to sustain the conversation about Marcel Duchamps? Well, by now, he probably already might.
Another Davis, this time the famous art critic Ben Davis of Artnet, six days after the auction at Christie’s, published his rather critical opinion-piece[2]. And rightly so. It suffices to scroll through the zoomed-in artworks that make up the mosaic of “Everydays” to see disturbing images, very questionable attempts at political satire, and images crossing all possible boundaries of what’s acceptable in the modern world… Racism, misogyny, you name it, he has it.
Ben Davis in his concluding paragraph of that opinion poses a good question: “During a time of immiseration, investors are competing to throw tens of millions of dollars… at this?”
The buyer, however, strongly disagrees, stating: “This is the crown jewel, the most valuable piece of art for this generation. It is worth $1 billion.” One might indeed argue that “Everydays” is an artistic time capsule in a way and it is a unique piece. Sort of.
Here to stress, that the next time you read about the immutable, 100% certain provenance, blockchain record et caetera, just remember: “Beeple and sleepminting”[3] and this is just one example of the NFT-related scams possible[4].
The bottom line is that NFTs have a lot of red flags and if one really appreciates a particular art or wants to support a particular artist or cause, art-NFTs are definitely to be looked into. If on the other hand, it is about making a high-ROI investment, then NFTs are probably not the way to go.
To conclude on Beeple:
Irrespective of the quality of his individual artworks making up “Everydays”, the significance of this mosaic lies in that it has certainly attracted general public’s attention, started extensive conversations around NFT topic, and essentially paved the way for many digital artists using this tool.[5] Therefore, it is safe to say that Mike Winkelmann, a.k.a. Beeple, has started the whole insaNFTy, shaking up the (art) world as we knew it.
One small .jpeg for a man, one giant leap for a mankind.
P.S. And where is Beeple now, you might wonder? He is still making digital art. Like he had been before NFTs and by his own assertion, “if all this f***ng NFT stuff went away tomorrow” would be doing in the future. Aside from that, as he shared in an interview during the "NFT In America" event several months ago (on 10/04/2022), he is still processing the Christie’s sale, and meanwhile building a 50,000-square-foot building in Charleston (South Carolina), which will host his studio, a gallery, and an “experiential space with tons of projectors”.
A real-world project for a change.
[1] To put things in perspective here, Instagram would not appear for 3,5 more years — it was launched only in October 2010.
[3] For more detailed read on the topic, have a look at the article here - https://timdaub.github.io/2021/04/22/nft-sleepminting-beeple-provenance/ or just “google” “beeple sleepminting” to get more hits. In a few words, this is a way to successfully tamper with the NFT's provenance record. And actually, also blockchain as such is not tamper-proof… Have a read here for instance - https://medium.com/@artusvranken/actually-there-could-be-a-way-to-delete-data-on-a-blockchain-df62964bd927
[4] Another one is PHAYC and PAYC - a story of two NFT copycats who mirrored famous BAYC (Bored Ape Yacht Club). But do not stop here, there are much more NFT scams out there.
[5] Or wait, was it all about Christie’s?…
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
Have you ever been a victim of a scam? or have you Suffered a loss from a Fraudulent Ponzi Scheme? I implore you to Contact DWOH, A Certified Cryptocurrency Assets Recovery Expert. I once fell victim to an online imposter who convinced me to invest in a Bogus Cryptocurrency scheme by claiming to have made large profits from the plan. My Mycelium wallet contained $579,000 in Crypto that I lost, I had been reporting to the Authorities tirelessly for a longtime without getting assistance before I finally got in touch with DWOH. Fortunately after a serious long chat with DWOH all my funds were recovered back.
I recommend this Expert to any victim who has lost Crypto to any fake online Schemes.
Talk to DWOH Through ;
Mail: [email protected]
WhatsApp: +18033921735
Website: www.darkwebonlinehackers.com
Read my review and contact him now for your own lottery winning numbers. It is a very hard situation when playing the lottery and never won, or keep winning low fund not up to 500 bucks, i have been a victim of such a tough life, the biggest fund i have ever won was 350 buck, and i have been playing the lottery for 8 years, things suddenly change the moment i came across a testimony of a voodoo doctor who help people in any type of lottery numbers, i was not easily convinced, but i decided to take try, after all done, i am proud to be a lottery winner with the help of Prophet Isaac, i won $8.500.000 and i am making this known to every one of you who have been trying to win the lottery, believe me this is the only way to win the lottery, this is the real secret we all have been looking for.
You can contact PROFESSOR ISAAC on his WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724
Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Email: [email protected]
Read my review and contact him now for your own lottery winning numbers. It is a very hard situation when playing the lottery and never won, or keep winning low fund not up to 500 bucks, i have been a victim of such a tough life, the biggest fund i have ever won was 350 buck, and i have been playing the lottery for 8 years, things suddenly change the moment i came across a testimony of a voodoo doctor who help people in any type of lottery numbers, i was not easily convinced, but i decided to take try, after all done, i am proud to be a lottery winner with the help of Prophet Isaac, i won $8.500.000 and i am making this known to every one of you who have been trying to win the lottery, believe me this is the only way to win the lottery, this is the real secret we all have been looking for.
You can contact PROFESSOR ISAAC on his WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724
Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Email: [email protected]
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
PROPHET ISAAC CAN FIX THE FOLLOWING PROBLEMS TO ALL ACROSS THE
GLOBE:
Get your ex back spell
Lottery Spell
Love/Reunion Spell
Pregnancy Spell
Protection Spell
Freedom From Prison Spell
Marriage spell
Healing/Cure spell
Judge a court case to you favor spell
Job promotion spell E.T.C
PROPHET ISAAC CAN FIX THE FOLLOWING PROBLEMS TO ALL ACROSS THE
GLOBE:
Get your ex back spell
Lottery Spell
Love/Reunion Spell
Pregnancy Spell
Protection Spell
Freedom From Prison Spell
Marriage spell
Healing/Cure spell
Judge a court case to you favor spell
Job promotion spell E.T.C
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.