Copyright protects artistic creations, but what about artist's style? Our returning author - Andrea Quintanilla - provides comparative overview of respective regulation in Europe, the USA and the Andean Community
Andrea Quintanilla
Protection of the artist's style: Comparative law
Copyright gives protection to intellectual creation that is original, covering a wide range of works such as: written works, artistic works, musical works, dramatic and choreographic works, computer programs, films and multimedia products. Thus, the way in which ideas are expressed is protected, and it is this expression that gives originality to a work.
However, copyright does not grant exclusive rights over ideas or facts, but over works.
Although it is true, lawyer Diego Guzmán says that it is often difficult to differentiate between ideas and expressions of ideas in practice. This can be seen in the case of works of art if it is the artist's own style. [1]
In the following, we will look at the development of the subject in general within the European Union, the United States and the Andean Community:
EUROPE
With regard to the European Directive, it has no rule protecting the artist's style, but considers "pastiche" as an exception and limitation to copyright. While the Directive allows its member countries to determine whether pastiche is anexception and limitation, it implicitly recognises that the rights of the rights-holder would be infringed in countries that do not incorporate the exception.
Let us first define "pastiche". According to the Royal Spanish Academy, the term pastiche is the imitation or plagiarism that consists of taking certain characteristic elements of an artist's work and combining them in such a way that they give the impression of being an independent creation. [2]
Spain provides a good example, where they introduced the pastiche limitation in 2022, reinforcing the legal scope of multimedia expressions and constructions that are replicated and shared via social networks to the public to great acclaim (such as memes). This limit is also extended within an analogue framework. Article 70 of Royal Decree-Law 24/2021 states that pastiche, which does not require the authorisation of the author or the owner of the work to make modifications, must clearly be intended as a joke.
Thus, Spanish law takes into account the need to innovate, as a result of new digital technologies that develop new forms of use.
It should be noted that the European Directive 2001/29/EC states in article 5 that member countries may include exceptions and limitations to copyright in relation to caricature, parody or pastiche.
Pastiche, as Fredric Jameson puts it, constitutes a kind of parody, both of which "involve the imitation or, better still, the imitation of other styles and, in particular, of their stylistic mannerisms and criss-crossings". [3]
UNITED STATES
In the case of the USA, the artist's own style is protected in court. This is thanks to the case Steinberg v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc. (1987).
Throughout the case, plaintiff Steinberg claimed that Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc.'s promotional poster for the film "Moscow on the Hudson" infringed his rights in the illustration he drew for the cover of the 29 March 1976 issue of The New Yorker magazine. Steinberg sued the film's producers, promoters, distributors and advertisers for copyright infringement. Also involved were RCA Corporation (RCA) and Diener Hauser Bates Co. (DHB) with Columbia for the film. Other defendants were later added to the complaint pursuant to a memorandum decision on the court on November 17, 1986. The latter were divided into two classes of defendants: the affiliates of Columbia and RCA who were handling the distribution of the film nationally and internationally, and the owners of the major newspapers that published allegedly infringing advertising. [4]
That poster featured the same style of stroke, visual composition and perspective as the work created by the artist Steinberg, however, it did not imitate particular elements. The defendants asserted affirmative defences of fair use such as parody, estoppel and statute of limitations. Following an analysis of precedent cases and the Second District judge's comparison of elements present in each work, a "comprehensive non-literal similarity test" was conducted. Subsequently, summary judgement was granted to the plaintiffs with respect to the copy.
The judge's conclusion was as follows:
"Even at first glance, the remarkable stylistic relationship between the posters can be seen, and since style is one of the ingredients of expression, this relationship is significant. The defendants' illustration was rendered in the sketch-like, creative style that has become Steinberg's trademark." [5]
Thus, it held that the proper style amounts to original expression safeguarded by copyright and based the infringement on the similarity of style between the two works. This is how a simple idea became a form of expression with great relevance to protect the artist.
ANDEAN COMMUNITY
Regarding the Andean Community and its member countries (Peru, Ecuador, Colombia, Bolivia), its legislation does not have regulations that protect the artist's style and distinguish it from ideas. However, the Judicial Tribunal of the Andean Community (TJCA) has pointed out the matter in its jurisprudence. Therefore, each member country has its own position to determine whether it is in a copyright infringement case, according to its domestic law.
Decision 351 does not refer to the artist's style or the figure of pastiche. On the other hand, the ECJ has repeatedly indicated that "the protected work must be original, with its own characteristics that make it different; what is protected is the author's individuality, originality and his own style for expressing his ideas". [6] Based on the above, the artist's style becomes a peculiarity of the expression protected by copyright.
CONCLUSION
The artist's own style is protected by copyright despite the difficulty of distinguishing ideas from expressions of ideas in practice.
Such legal protection is evident in the European Union, the United States and the Andean Community. Within the EU, style is slightly safeguarded by exceptions and limitations that allow the imitation of the artist's own style, even if the rule does not expressly provide for any protection. On the other hand, in the case of the USA, we are faced with a much more evident safeguard as there is a concrete application given by American jurisprudence. Finally, the Andean case can be compared with the American case if we look at the jurisprudence of the ECJ, which expressly refers to the protection of the author's own style by copyright. Although Andean legislation does not yet have an exception or limitation that allows the figure of pastiche, the imitation of the artist's style in Andean territory would be an act of infringement of the right of transformation.
REFERENCES
[1] Diego Guzmán, “Protección del estilo del artista”. In: Derecho del Arte. Bogotá: Universidad Externado de Colombia, 2018, p. 58-60.
[2] Definition of “pastiche” according to Real Academia Española. In: https://dle.rae.es/pastiche.
[3] Fredric Jameson, “Postmodernism and consumer society”. In: Postmodern culture. London: Pluto Press, 1985, p. 114.
[4] Antonio Perdices, “El límite del pastiche: Primera aplicaciones de los tribunales en Alemania”. in: Blog CIPI. May 27, 2022. https://blog.cipi.es/blog2-intelectual/item/223-el-limite-del-pastiche-primeras-aplicaciones-de-los-tribunales-en-alemania.
[5] Corte del Distrito Sur de Nueva York, Steinberg v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 663 F.Supp. 706 (1987), p. 712.
[6] Tribunal de Justicia de la Comunidad Andina, Interpretación Prejudicial, Proceso 20-IP-2007, 18 de abril de 2007.
[7] Corte del Distrito Sur de Nueva York, Steinberg v. Columbia Pictures Industries, Inc., 663 ESupp. 706 (1987), p. 712.
[8] El Confidencial, “Los memes alcanzan rango de ley por indicación de la Unión Europea”. In: https://blogs.elconfidencial.com/espana/el-confidente/2022-01-11/memes-alcanzan-rango-ley-indicacion-union-europea_3356203/.
[9] The Legal Artist, “You can’t copyright style”. February 01, 2016. In: https://www.thelegalartist.com/blog/you-cant-copyright-style.
[10] WIPO, “Aprender del pasado para crear el futuro: Las creaciones artísticas y el derecho de autor”. In: https://www.wipo.int/edocs/pubdocs/es/copyright/935/wipo_pub_935.pdf
Images provided for by the authors
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
I just have to testify about this here and let everyone know how much better I feel right now. I had over $800k in bitcoin Lost to a fake investor online that I came across last three mouths through a colleague of mine at work which also lost her investment along the line though she has been investing with the company for months too and been paid out severally before this happened tried reaching the team but did not get any feedback for several weeks, at some point I thought about getting a hacker to see if that will help and then I read about a team called GEO COORDINATES RECOVERY HACKER. They helped people retrieve their lost funds in investment or even stolen from their bank accounts. I reached out to him without hesitating and the outcome was wonderful. After retrieving the whole money he also worked for my colleague and is in the final stage of retrieving the last investment she made. Thank you for the heroic work you do for the helpless and hopeless. If you find it hard to reach him through email then contact him through
Email: [email protected]
Website; https://geovcoordinateshac.wixsite.com/geo-coordinates-hack
WhatsApp ( +1 (512) 550 1646 )
Read my review and contact him now for your own lottery winning numbers. It is a very hard situation when playing the lottery and never won, or keep winning low fund not up to 500 bucks, i have been a victim of such a tough life, the biggest fund i have ever won was 350 buck, and i have been playing the lottery for 8 years, things suddenly change the moment i came across a testimony of a voodoo doctor who help people in any type of lottery numbers, i was not easily convinced, but i decided to take try, after all done, i am proud to be a lottery winner with the help of Prophet Isaac, i won $8.500.000 and i am making this known to every one of you who have been trying to win the lottery, believe me this is the only way to win the lottery, this is the real secret we all have been looking for.
You can contact PROFESSOR ISAAC on his WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724
Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Email: [email protected]
Read my review and contact him now for your own lottery winning numbers. It is a very hard situation when playing the lottery and never won, or keep winning low fund not up to 500 bucks, i have been a victim of such a tough life, the biggest fund i have ever won was 350 buck, and i have been playing the lottery for 8 years, things suddenly change the moment i came across a testimony of a voodoo doctor who help people in any type of lottery numbers, i was not easily convinced, but i decided to take try, after all done, i am proud to be a lottery winner with the help of Prophet Isaac, i won $8.500.000 and i am making this known to every one of you who have been trying to win the lottery, believe me this is the only way to win the lottery, this is the real secret we all have been looking for.
You can contact PROFESSOR ISAAC on his WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724
Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Email: [email protected]
Have you ever been a victim of a scam? or have you Suffered a loss from a Fraudulent Ponzi Scheme? I implore you to Contact DWOH, A Certified Cryptocurrency Assets Recovery Expert. I once fell victim to an online imposter who convinced me to invest in a Bogus Cryptocurrency scheme by claiming to have made large profits from the plan. My Mycelium wallet contained $579,000 in Crypto that I lost, I had been reporting to the Authorities tirelessly for a longtime without getting assistance before I finally got in touch with DWOH. Fortunately after a serious long chat with DWOH all my funds were recovered back.
I recommend this Expert to any victim who has lost Crypto to any fake online Schemes.
Talk to DWOH Through ;
Mail: [email protected]
WhatsApp: +18033921735
Website: www.darkwebonlinehackers.com
PROPHET ISAAC CAN FIX THE FOLLOWING PROBLEMS TO ALL ACROSS THE GLOBE:
Get your ex back spell
Lottery Spell
Love/Reunion Spell
Pregnancy Spell
Protection Spell
Freedom From Prison Spell
Marriage spell
Healing/Cure spell
Judge a court case to you favor spell
Job promotion spell E.T.C
PROPHET ISAAC CAN FIX THE FOLLOWING PROBLEMS TO ALL ACROSS THE GLOBE:
Get your ex back spell
Lottery Spell
Love/Reunion Spell
Pregnancy Spell
Protection Spell
Freedom From Prison Spell
Marriage spell
Healing/Cure spell
Judge a court case to you favor spell
Job promotion spell E.T.C
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
+1(779) 324-0633 anywhere in the world you want to be rich, famous, and posses power.
email [email protected] for more
info...
BENEFITS GIVEN TO NEW MEMBERS
1. A Cash Reward of $500,000.00
2.A New CAR valued at $30,000.00
3. A new house worth $100,000.00 in your country
4.One Month holiday (fully paid) to your dream tourist destination.
5. Influence your brand/business worldwide
6. Protection from all oppressors
7.A total Lifestyle change
8.Access to Bohemian Grove
9. Booked Appointment with Top Leaders and Top Celebrities in your country.
WARNING DO NOT CONTACT US IF YOU ARE NOT INTERRESTED.