Summarize

Artificial intelligence is gathering speed in all the spheres of life, including creative field. Do the AI creations enjoy copyright protection or do they fall a priori within the public domain?

Ryan E. Long

AI Creations: Legally Protected?

Imagine you just purchased a painting from Sotheby’s called Portrait of Edmond Belamy (“Portrait”) for $432,500. Portrait was AI-generated. Your neighbour Jim takes a photo of the painting as you are bringing it inside. Jim puts Portrait on t-shirts for sale online.

What, if anything, can you do, provided you wanted to? What about the software company who owns the AI? Does it matter whether you live in the US or the EU?

The issue is not hypothetical. AI-created paintings, software, and other inventions have grown immensely. While copyright and patent law can protect human-made paintings and software, respectively, AI-generated inventions are not protectable under either regime in the US. In the EU, the answer is largely the same, as we shall see below.

 

Can AI be an “author” or “inventor”?

A. The European Union

The European Patent Office on 28 January 2020 rejected patent filings by a machine called DABUS on the same grounds that “an inventor designated in the application has to be a human being, and not a machine.” In both applications, “a machine called ‘DABUS,’ which is described as a ‘type of connectionist artificial intelligence,’ is named as the inventor.” As we shall see, decisions regarding copyright and patent ownership in the US follow a similar rationale.

Thereafter, the European Parliament passed a number of resolutions concerning AI throughout 2020. A report “on intellectual property rights for the development of artificial intelligence technologies” from 10 October 2020 is most relevant for the purposes of this article. It recommends that, in apportioning intellectual property rights, “the degree of human intervention” and “autonomy of AI” should be taken into account.

The report goes onto note “the difference between AI-assisted human creations and AI-generated creations, with the latter creating new challenges for IPR [intellectual property rights] protection, such as questions of ownership, inventorship and appropriate renumeration.” The Report recommends that “works autonomously produced by artificial agents and robots might not be eligible for copyright protection, in order to preserve the principle of originality, which is linked to a natural person.”. As such, “ownership rights, if any, should be assigned to natural or legal persons that created the work lawfully.”

On October 20, 2020, the European Parliament adopted the recommendations and refined them via a Resolution. For example, while AI and related technologies “based on computations models an algorithms” and regarded as “mathematical methods” are not patentable,” such models and computer programs may be protected “when they are used as part of an AI system that contributes to producing a further technical effect.” (Emphasis added.)

The Resolution goes on to clarify that “where AI is used only as a tool to assist an author in the process of creation, the current IP framework remains applicable.” (Emphasis added.) In all cases, only a natural person can be listed as the inventor of a copyright or patent in the EU.

That all being said, the 20 October Resolution does not state whether the author needs to delineate in the application which parts of the creation were AI made, and which were created by the author. This approach is how copyrights for compositions by multiple authors are filed in the US – denoting by whom among the authors certain lyrics or musical notes were written. A similar approach could be used for a subsequent Resolution.

 

B. The United States

Copyright case law has also indicated that AI cannot be an “author” under the Copyright Act. In Naurto v. Slater, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that an Indonesian monkey named “Naruto” couldn’t own the copyright to his “Monkey Selfies.” The reason: the U.S. Copyright office “will refuse to register a claim if it determines that a human being did not create the work.” (Emphasis added.) The office further states that it will exclude works “produced by machine or mere mechanical process that operates randomly or automatically without any creative input or intervention from a human author.” (Emphasis added.) Consequently, AI-created products are not likely subject to copyright registration.

Similarly, the USPTO, in a April 27, 2020 decision ruled that AI cannot be listed as the “inventor” in a patent application. The application was filed by the Artificial Inventor Project (“AIP”), which is a team of international patent attorneys whose mission is to explore AI patentability. AIP filed a sealed patent application on July 29, 2019, for “Devices and Methods for Attracting Enhanced Attention (“DABUS application”). According to the application, this “creativity machine” is “programmed as a series of neural networks that have been trained with general information in the field of endeavor to independently create the invention.” The inventor on the substitute application was listed as “DABUS (the invention was autonomously generated by artificial intelligence).”

Under relevant federal patent law, an “inventor” is defined as “the individual or, if a joint invention, the individuals collectively who invented or discovered the subject matter of the invention.” However, the USPTO’s decision denying the DABUS application pointed out that federal law consistently refers to inventors as natural persons. One section provides “[w]hoever invents or discovers any new and useful process . . . may obtain a patent therefore”. According to the USPTO, “’[w]hoever’ suggests a natural person.” Other provisions of federal patent law “refers to individuals and uses pronouns specific to natural persons  -- ‘himself’ and ‘herself’ – when referring to the ‘individual’ who believes himself or herself to be the original inventor or an original joint inventor or a claimed invention on the application.” The finding of the USPTO is consistent with Federal Circuit case law which has held that an “inventor” must be a natural person.

Like in the E.U., a creation may still be copyrightable or patentable in the U.S. if it was made with the assistance of AI. The question of how much AI involvement renders an otherwise human-made creation a product of AI has yet to be addressed.

 

How to protect AI creations?

If AI creations are not, for the time being, protectable under either copyright or patent, then how can one protect them? Contractual provisions in licensing agreements are one option. Even if licensed technology isn’t either copyrightable or patentable, contract law can provide a gap filler between contracting parties. However, this doesn’t preclude reverse engineering once the product is released into the market. Another alternative is federal or state trade secret law. Even then, trade secret law doesn’t preclude reverse engineering.

In light of these open questions, the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) held a conference in late 2020 to address ownership of AI created works. One question in WIPO’s Revised Issues Paper: “[i]f a human inventor is required to be named, should AI-generated inventions fall within the public domain or should the law given indications of the way in which the human inventor should be determined?” Likewise, the U.S. Copyright Office held a conference in February of 2020 year titled: Copyright in the Age of Artificial Intelligence and, later in the year, the USPTO published a report “Public Views on Artificial Intelligence and Intellectual Property Policy. The USPTO Report confirmed that AI cannot “invent nor author without human invention.”

Given the foregoing, you would not likely be able to enjoin Jim from commercially exploiting Portrait in either the EU or the US. As for the software company that created Portrait via its AI, the answer would, in all likelihood, be the same.

 

This article first appeared in Epicenter -- European Policy Information Center.

Since 2006, Ryan has been the principal of Long & Associates PLLC, a Santa Monica based boutique law practice. His e-mail: [email protected]. He solves tricky intellectual property issues for pioneering tech / media / design clients. They include interior designers like Ms. Allison Cosmos and fine artists such as painter Mr. William Petty, based within the U.S. and beyond. Ryan is also a non-residential fellow of Stanford Law School’s Center for Internet and Society. He has written for or been interviewed by the likes of TechCrunch, among others, about artificial intelligence, blockchain, and how to tackle “deep fake” content.

 

Photo on preview: by Andrea De Santis on Unsplash

Comments: 20
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 16, 2024 03:58
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 16, 2024 03:56
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 16, 2024 03:47
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 16, 2024 03:47
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 16, 2024 03:46
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Mariam Wilson
Aug 10, 2024 20:15
I owe my marriage to Prophet Isaac. For years, he has used his divine love spells to help me resolve conflicts with my spouse. As retirement approached, I was aware that life after work would present its challenges, so I sought Prophet Isaac guidance. He assured me that I would win the lottery if I followed his directions precisely. I gathered the necessary items for the lottery spell and, with confidence, shared my retirement plans with my employer, who confirmed July 17 as my retirement date. Three days later, I visited a J&J Variety convenience store in West Boylston, Mass, as Prophet Isaac had directed, and to my astonishment, I won $1,000,000. I opted for the cash option of $650,000. I am truly grateful to Prophet Isaac. Please join me in thanking him through email: ([email protected]) WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724 or Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Mariam Wilson
Aug 10, 2024 20:15
I owe my marriage to Prophet Isaac. For years, he has used his divine love spells to help me resolve conflicts with my spouse. As retirement approached, I was aware that life after work would present its challenges, so I sought Prophet Isaac guidance. He assured me that I would win the lottery if I followed his directions precisely. I gathered the necessary items for the lottery spell and, with confidence, shared my retirement plans with my employer, who confirmed July 17 as my retirement date. Three days later, I visited a J&J Variety convenience store in West Boylston, Mass, as Prophet Isaac had directed, and to my astonishment, I won $1,000,000. I opted for the cash option of $650,000. I am truly grateful to Prophet Isaac. Please join me in thanking him through email: ([email protected]) WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724 or Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Mariam Wilson
Aug 10, 2024 20:14
I owe my marriage to Prophet Isaac. For years, he has used his divine love spells to help me resolve conflicts with my spouse. As retirement approached, I was aware that life after work would present its challenges, so I sought Prophet Isaac guidance. He assured me that I would win the lottery if I followed his directions precisely. I gathered the necessary items for the lottery spell and, with confidence, shared my retirement plans with my employer, who confirmed July 17 as my retirement date. Three days later, I visited a J&J Variety convenience store in West Boylston, Mass, as Prophet Isaac had directed, and to my astonishment, I won $1,000,000. I opted for the cash option of $650,000. I am truly grateful to Prophet Isaac. Please join me in thanking him through email: ([email protected]) WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724 or Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Mariam Wilson
Aug 10, 2024 20:12
I owe my marriage to Prophet Isaac. For years, he has used his divine love spells to help me resolve conflicts with my spouse. As retirement approached, I was aware that life after work would present its challenges, so I sought Prophet Isaac guidance. He assured me that I would win the lottery if I followed his directions precisely. I gathered the necessary items for the lottery spell and, with confidence, shared my retirement plans with my employer, who confirmed July 17 as my retirement date. Three days later, I visited a J&J Variety convenience store in West Boylston, Mass, as Prophet Isaac had directed, and to my astonishment, I won $1,000,000. I opted for the cash option of $650,000. I am truly grateful to Prophet Isaac. Please join me in thanking him through email: ([email protected]) WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724 or Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/RealWhiteMagicSpell
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 07, 2024 00:15
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 07, 2024 00:15
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 07, 2024 00:11
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 07, 2024 00:11
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 07, 2024 00:11
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Maria Schaeffler
Aug 07, 2024 00:10
I feel so blessed again in my marriage after Doctor Oku brought back my husband that separated with me for a good 3 months. Even though I have mouths all over my body, it won't be enough to thank Doctor Oku for his help in my life. My husband separated with me for 3 months and has been in pain and agony without him. So, I searched for help everywhere but nothing worked out, not until I meant Doctor Oku who I contacted online. I explained my situation to him and he promised that my husband will get back to me within 48 to 72 hours as long as my heart still beats for him. I believed in him and he prepared a spell for me and my husband called me exactly when Doctor Oku said. He pleaded and said he needs me back and now we are living happily again for the past 9 months. Everyone out there reading my article that needs help should contact him... Email: [email protected] or whatsApp him +2347053113465
Laura Remy
Aug 06, 2024 19:29
How to Recover Cryptocurrency from fraudulent investment platforms.

Have you ever been a victim of a scam? or have you Suffered a loss from a Fraudulent Ponzi Scheme? I implore you to Contact DWOH, A Certified Cryptocurrency Assets Recovery Expert. I once fell victim to an online imposter who convinced me to invest in a Bogus Cryptocurrency scheme by claiming to have made large profits from the plan. My Mycelium wallet contained $579,000 in Crypto that I lost, I had been reporting to the Authorities tirelessly for a longtime without getting assistance before I finally got in touch with DWOH. Fortunately after a serious long chat with DWOH all my funds were recovered back.
I recommend this Expert to any victim who has lost Crypto to any fake online Schemes.

Talk to DWOH Through ;
Mail: [email protected]
WhatsApp: +18033921735
Website: www.darkwebonlinehackers.com
Laura Remy
Aug 06, 2024 19:29
How to Recover Cryptocurrency from fraudulent investment platforms.

Have you ever been a victim of a scam? or have you Suffered a loss from a Fraudulent Ponzi Scheme? I implore you to Contact DWOH, A Certified Cryptocurrency Assets Recovery Expert. I once fell victim to an online imposter who convinced me to invest in a Bogus Cryptocurrency scheme by claiming to have made large profits from the plan. My Mycelium wallet contained $579,000 in Crypto that I lost, I had been reporting to the Authorities tirelessly for a longtime without getting assistance before I finally got in touch with DWOH. Fortunately after a serious long chat with DWOH all my funds were recovered back.
I recommend this Expert to any victim who has lost Crypto to any fake online Schemes.

Talk to DWOH Through ;
Mail: [email protected]
WhatsApp: +18033921735
Website: www.darkwebonlinehackers.com
Haris
Aug 04, 2024 14:34
Es nekad nedomāju, ka publicēšu šo ziņojumu. Notika liela lieta, kas mainīja manu pasauli. Saņēmu kredītu, veiksmīgi nomaksāju parādus, šobrīd dzīve jūtas labi. Man bija parādi, man steidzami vajadzēja naudu, un vairāki tiešsaistes uzņēmumi, ar kuriem es sazinājos, izkrāpa mani no tā, kas man bija. mana draudzene Emīlija mani novirzīja uz Westlake Loan, tāpēc es pieteicos un parakstīju viņu līgumu ar advokātu, un viss. ja jums ir nepieciešams godīgs uzņēmums, kuram varat uzticēties, lai pieteiktos kredītam, ļoti iesaku sazināties ar [email protected]
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
Haris
Aug 04, 2024 14:34
Es nekad nedomāju, ka publicēšu šo ziņojumu. Notika liela lieta, kas mainīja manu pasauli. Saņēmu kredītu, veiksmīgi nomaksāju parādus, šobrīd dzīve jūtas labi. Man bija parādi, man steidzami vajadzēja naudu, un vairāki tiešsaistes uzņēmumi, ar kuriem es sazinājos, izkrāpa mani no tā, kas man bija. mana draudzene Emīlija mani novirzīja uz Westlake Loan, tāpēc es pieteicos un parakstīju viņu līgumu ar advokātu, un viss. ja jums ir nepieciešams godīgs uzņēmums, kuram varat uzticēties, lai pieteiktos kredītam, ļoti iesaku sazināties ar [email protected]
telegramma___https://t.me/loan59
MARIACOLBY
Jul 30, 2024 15:57
I'm so excited that my husband and I are back together, after a long separation. Thanks to the great prophet Isaac who helped me get my husband back, with his powerful love spell. I got Prophet Isaac details from the internet and contacted him, he was so polite and very reasonable, he asked me a few questions and I answered him, he gave me instructions and I followed them, within 24 hours of doing what he asked, my husband called me and begged me to come back . Do not hesitate to contact him. He is real, reliable and can also be very trusted. Contact him via WhatsApp: +1 (757) 237-1724 or by email: [email protected], he is 100% efficient and reliable.
We use cookies to help provide you with the best experience we can on our platform. By continuing to browse this site you accept and agree with this practice
Agree